When someone loses their life because of another person’s driving, no sentence can undo the damage. But the punishment must reflect the seriousness of the offence, and the consequences must be strong enough to deter others from taking the same reckless risks.
My constituent, Keely Morgan, was just 15 when she was killed by a car while crossing the road in Caerau, Cardiff West, in May 2023. She was a much-loved daughter, granddaughter, sister and friend, with her whole life ahead of her.
The court heard that the driver had been travelling above the speed limit, driving erratically and showing off. He had also removed the vehicle’s black box, invalidating his insurance. The judge described him as an “irresponsible show-off”.
He received only 16 months’ imprisonment for causing death by careless driving, alongside a concurrent sentence for driving while uninsured. He was released after serving just six and a half months.
Keely’s family must live with their loss for the rest of their lives. Her mother, Sian Morgan, has channelled her grief into a campaign for change, gathering more than 10,000 signatures.
Sian wants to ensure that no other family has to endure the indignity her family has suffered. They cannot bring Keely back, and no sentence can make up for her loss. But they should not have to fight to have the seriousness of her death recognised. Their campaign is about making sure the law does more to hold offenders accountable and deter others from making similarly devastating choices.
Sadly, these concerns are not new in Cardiff West. Almost a decade ago, my predecessor raised similar questions after another constituent was killed when two drivers deliberately pursued her and drove her off the road. Both were convicted of causing death by dangerous driving and received prison sentences of just six and a half and seven and a half years respectively.
Almost ten years later, I find myself representing the same constituency and raising similar concerns. We must ask why families continue to question whether sentences reflect the gravity of their loss.
The Government must now consider four areas for reform.
First, sentencing guidelines for fatal careless and dangerous driving should be reviewed. Excessive speed, deliberate risk-taking, previous offending and disregard for safety must receive appropriate weight. Courts must retain discretion to consider individual circumstances, but sentences must reflect the seriousness of the conduct and the consequences. They must also send a clear message that reckless driving carries serious consequences.
Secondly, driving disqualifications must be examined. Driving is a privilege, not a right. Where serious offending demonstrates a disregard for other people’s safety, there should be robust safeguards before an individual returns to the road. Sian’s proposal for automatic licence revocation following serious traffic incidents, notably before an appearance at court or before conviction by a court, alongside mandatory reassessment before driving privileges are restored, deserves proper consideration.
Thirdly, the Government should consider whether stronger custodial sentences are needed in the most serious cases, including whether suspended sentences are appropriate where a life has been lost. Prison cannot bring back a loved one, but meaningful penalties can reinforce accountability and help deter dangerous behaviour. We must be prepared to ask whether the sentences available and imposed are sufficient.
Fourthly, we must tackle repeat offending and strengthen prevention. The Government should review whether existing penalties adequately address patterns of irresponsible driving before they lead to tragedy. Stronger sentences alone will not solve every road safety problem. Effective enforcement, education and safer infrastructure must also play their part.
Deterrence matters because drivers must understand that reckless decisions can have serious consequences. The law cannot guarantee that every tragedy will be prevented, but it should do everything reasonably possible to discourage dangerous behaviour and protect the public.
This is not about revenge. It is about accountability, prevention and ensuring that the consequences of fatal driving offences are proportionate to the harm caused.
Every day, residents cross the zebra crossing on Heol Trelai. For the Caerau community, it remains a reminder of Keely and the life lost there. I pay tribute to Sian and her family for turning their grief into a determined campaign for change.
Keely should have been able to cross that road safely and return home. Her family should be able to remember her for the person she was, rather than having to fight to ensure that other families are spared their suffering.
When families from the same constituency raise the same concerns almost a decade apart, Parliament must listen. The Government must review the sentencing framework and take meaningful action so that offenders are held accountable, penalties provide a genuine deterrent, and families can have confidence that the law takes these offences as seriously as it should.





